PTI government added $10.4 billion in the foreign loans in the first six months of 2021-22

 Government borrowing increased 78% during July-December 2021 compare to the same period last year

Contrary to the claims of PTI government to reduce the burden of loans, Pakistan’s debts are rising at fast pace. PTI government is borrowing more than any government did in the history of Pakistan. The government spokesmen also give the wrong justification that PTI government is taking new loans to repay the loans taken by the previous governments of PPP and PML-N. The government is also taking most expensive loans to bridge the financial gaps.  

But the data of both Ministry of Finance and State Bank of Pakistan contradicts the PTI claims. The data shows that government is taking new loans to finance the budget deficit and to build the foreign Reserves.

According to a report published in Express Tribune on January 27 by Shahbaz Rana revealed that PTI government has borrowed $10.4 billion as foreign loans during first six months of current financial year 2021-22.

This amount is 78% more than borrowed during the same period last year. This growing borrowing during the current financial year is the clear indication that government is struggling to close the gap in the budget and current account deficits.  The PTI government is also facing problems to maintain the fast depleting foreign reserves.

Shahbaz Rana has quoted Ministry of Economic Affairs in the report and provided details of foreign loans obtained during July-December period.  “Gross foreign loan disbursements during July-December of current fiscal year remained at $9.3 billion.

The government received $1.1 billion in foreign loans from the overseas Pakistanis through the Naya Pakistan Certificates, the central bank data showed. The cumulative gross foreign loans secured in the first half of current fiscal year were higher by $4.5 billion, or 78%, from the same period of previous fiscal year, showed the official statistics.”

The Debt Policy Statement 2021-22 showed that contrary to the claims of the government that the debt burden was increasing due to the repayment of old loans, the external debt repayments, in fact, decreased $2.1 billion, or 23.3%, in the last fiscal year compared to the preceding year.

The Shahbaz Rana also pointed out that “the highly expensive Naya Pakistan Certificates-backed loans are a new debt instrument that the PTI government has added to the list. The $1.1 billion loan from July through December of current fiscal year was acquired at 7% interest rate in dollar terms. The foreign loans of $9.3 billion, reported by the Ministry of Economic Affairs, are inclusive of the $3 billion short-term loan received from Saudi Arabia last month.”

However, despite the Saudi Arabian assistance, the gross official foreign exchange reserves dipped to $17.1 billion by mid-January, sufficient to finance hardly 10 weeks of imports. An amount of $2 billion was received in foreign commercial loans from banks in the first six months of current fiscal year, including $502 million in December.

The government borrowed $1.1 billion from Dubai Bank, including a fresh contract for $420 million. Another loan of $487 million was taken from Standard Chartered Bank, London, according to the economic affairs ministry. A financing of $343 million was secured from Credit Suisse AG.

Overall, 84% of the loans, or $8.7 billion, were taken for non-productive purposes like budget financing, crude oil import and foreign exchange reserves’ building. Owing to the increasing reliance on loans to enhance the country’s foreign currency reserves and finance the budget deficit, the cost of debt servicing has gone up significantly.

The average maturity time of external debt deteriorated from last year’s level of seven years to six years and eight months by the end of June 2021. The share of foreign commercial loans has already increased from 11% to 13% in the external public debt.

Official statistics showed that bilateral lending to Pakistan almost dried up in the current fiscal year, standing at a mere $94 million so far for project financing. This included $73.4 million in project lending by China. The government has not yet been able to secure a fresh commitment of $6 billion from China for financing the Main Line-I railway project of China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC).

Pakistan also obtained loans worth $2.8 billion from multilateral creditors. The Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank released $36 million for project financing.

Amongst other multilateral development partners, the Asian Development Bank (ADB) disbursed $1.1 billion during the July-December period, including $488 million for vaccine procurement.

The World Bank released $932 million in the six months under review while the Islamic Development Bank disbursed $805 million for crude oil imports. The Ministry of Economic Affairs also booked $291 million worth of publicly guaranteed debt, which China disbursed for Karachi’s nuclear power plants, known as K2 and K3.

The government also took $10 million in loan from NBP Bahrain to finance the losses of Roosevelt Hotel, New York, which was owned by the loss-making Pakistan International Airlines.

                                                                           Khalid Bhatti